Isotoxin wrote:
Actually, I don't think he has to give you a credit. Since the boat is copied from another map. Nalisazure, if i'm not mistaking. And a plant and a shit, Idk but, i saw that bout 1000000000000 times already.
Pardon me, but where does Creavion say that Thunder has to give
him credit? Like Creavion said, about UT2k4 stuff he ripped, credits are also imo unecessary if the content remains exactly the same as if anyone ripped it, modified material is another story. But he talked about the 7-bullets stuff which is original content from the team.
Plus, only because something was reused thousands of times, that doesn't discard the credits giving specially when the author(s) request to.
For instance, imagine you have a work to do, and you need images, I am sure the first thing you will do is type "google.com" and use the first image you find... but guess what, if your work is published or even if it's just to school, what you just did was "steal" that image and saying it's yours, plus many images on the web have rights on them so you cannot even use them for your stuff, even giving credits. However it's on the web and perhaps used in many places, but yet they're not yours.
For instance, everytime I need an image (at work), I have to create it most of the times or be absolutelly sure it's ok to use it. Even for a flash game I did for school once had all the images from me created from scratch, all because our teacher said to be carefull with that, and so to not have absolutelly any problem, I did my own.
And another thing: some modders go to the actual industry, specially when the studios look up something they liked. Imagine what is a studio finding something very good and wanting to contact who made it, who they will contact? Well, since you didn't give credits, besides your own most likelly, they will contact you, then you have 3 options: give out who actually made it and you will be seen with bad eyes, saying it was you and then 1 week later go to jail when they find out the truth or simply say you don't know and screwing who actually "helped" your "thing" to be possible in the first place.
I know this last example was a bit to the "extreme", I know, but yeah, credits are quite important and is exactly what keeps many software free and keeps order and organization among developers.