No worries, it's not ranked. Because art is subjective and I'm very indecisive, ranking that list would take me daysCreavion wrote:Oh I see, its a ranking list after all and I am one of the "worst of the best"?
Anyway: DavidM is FAR to high on the list. KaMi is FAR to low scheduled.
There's far too many qualities to consider.
What I did was put more of the 'oldschool' mappers first, then whomever came to mind.
And yes, looking at DavidM's work compared to FoT maps or the like, some would question whether he should be on there at all. But he popularized alot of things and understood gameplay very well, I'm sure if he was still mapping today that the aesthetic qualities of his work would've been up to par with FoT. Kind of like when Hourences released DOM-Horean.
http://www.mapraider.com/maps/?fileid=3968
I can say with certainty that visually, L.J paranoid is my favorite.
Gameplay-wise would be SabbathCat.