medor wrote:HI
I asked for details on the various AudioDevice for UT.If you have experience in there it'd be nice to explain me that.
What is the best AudioDevice ? Galaxy, ALAudio, FMODAudioDrv, Other ?
What settings ?
Code: Select all
AudioDevice=Galaxy.GalaxyAudioSubsystem [Galaxy.GalaxyAudioSubsystem] UseDirectSound=True UseFilter=True UseSurround=False UseStereo=True UseCDMusic=False UseDigitalMusic=True UseSpatial=False UseReverb=True Use3dHardware=False LowSoundQuality=False ReverseStereo=False Latency=70 OutputRate=22050Hz EffectsChannels=16 DopplerSpeed=9000.000000 MusicVolume=32 SoundVolume=96 AmbientFactor=0.700000
Code: Select all
AudioDevice=ALAudio.ALAudioSubsystem [ALAudio.ALAudioSubsystem] ALDevices=DefaultDevice FMODDevices=DefaultDevice FMODOutputs=DSOUND DopplerFactor=0.01 UseOriginalUnreal=True SoundVolume=200 UseReverb=True AmbientFactor=0.700000 MusicVolume=130 MusicPanSeparation=0.800000 Channels=64 OutputRate=48000Hz UseDigitalMusic=True bSoundAttenuate=False
Code: Select all
AudioDevice=FMODAudioDrv.FMODAudioDevice [FMODAudioDrv.FMODAudioDevice] FMODDevices=DefaultDevice FMODOutputs=DSOUND UseOriginalUnreal=True SoundVolume=200 UseReverb=True AmbientFactor=0.700000 UseHardwareChannels=False MusicVolume=130 MusicPanSeparation=0.800000 UseDigitalMusic=True Channels=64 UseCDMusic=False OutputRate=48000Hz Speakers=Stereo bSoundAttenuate=False DopplerSpeed=6500
UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
- papercoffee
- Godlike
- Posts: 10447
- Joined: Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:36 am
- Personal rank: coffee addicted !!!
- Location: Cologne, the city with the big cathedral.
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
To be honest ...I never changed the audio device... I'd only set it to the best quality in-game. Didn't know this is also possible lol.
- Feralidragon
- Godlike
- Posts: 5493
- Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2008 6:24 pm
- Personal rank: Work In Progress
- Location: Liandri
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
I never used anything other than the default that comes with the game relative sound: Galaxy.
So I don't know trully which one is best, but the default one never gave me trouble or performance issues ever.
The only reason you would have to switch to another one would be only to support certain features, like stereo wav files (which Galaxy doesn't support), but in another hand using stereo sounds in a game like UT won't make that much of a difference and would simply occupy 2x the space, besides mods with stereo sounds will always crash 90% of the players for sure, since only a few change from Galaxy to another anyway.
There are other features you may want though, which only newer sound drivers give to you, only in that case I think using another other than Galaxy is justifiable.
So I don't know trully which one is best, but the default one never gave me trouble or performance issues ever.
The only reason you would have to switch to another one would be only to support certain features, like stereo wav files (which Galaxy doesn't support), but in another hand using stereo sounds in a game like UT won't make that much of a difference and would simply occupy 2x the space, besides mods with stereo sounds will always crash 90% of the players for sure, since only a few change from Galaxy to another anyway.
There are other features you may want though, which only newer sound drivers give to you, only in that case I think using another other than Galaxy is justifiable.
- Hook
- Inhuman
- Posts: 754
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2008 11:21 pm
- Personal rank: UT99 Promoter/Admin
- Location: Minnesota USA
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Galaxy is all I ever use or used also, and Like Feralidragon, I never had any issues with it either.
If you do use Galaxy, I might point out that it does use stereo sounds, just not stereo Wave sounds.
I think that is what Feralidragon was saying - is that correct Feralidragon?
If you do use Galaxy, I might point out that it does use stereo sounds, just not stereo Wave sounds.
I think that is what Feralidragon was saying - is that correct Feralidragon?
=Hook=(Member# 626)
HUTP Active Forums: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/forum
HUTP UT99 Community Portal: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/
OR: https://hermskii.com/hook/ut99_hutp/
UT99 Server -> CROSSBONES Missile Madness {CMM}
* Newest Versions of: PRO-Redeemers | PRO-SNIPER-Redeemers | PRO-SEEKER-Redeemers <-(the Original)
and Now with FOOD FIGHT and Frying Pan arena !!!
IP: 68.232.181.236:7777 <-(NEW IP to come)
UT99 MH Server -> {CMH} CROSSBONES Monster Hunt (MH) by Mars007 (The Original) - IP: 108.61.238.93:7777
HUTP Active Forums: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/forum
HUTP UT99 Community Portal: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/
OR: https://hermskii.com/hook/ut99_hutp/
UT99 Server -> CROSSBONES Missile Madness {CMM}
* Newest Versions of: PRO-Redeemers | PRO-SNIPER-Redeemers | PRO-SEEKER-Redeemers <-(the Original)
and Now with FOOD FIGHT and Frying Pan arena !!!
IP: 68.232.181.236:7777 <-(NEW IP to come)
UT99 MH Server -> {CMH} CROSSBONES Monster Hunt (MH) by Mars007 (The Original) - IP: 108.61.238.93:7777
- Saya-chan
- Adept
- Posts: 446
- Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 10:46 am
- Personal rank: Former UT99 modder
- Location: Vigo, Galicia
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Well, the OpenAL device does support stereo sound files. It even supports modern tracker music files with lots of channels. But I only know of two things that make me change back to Galaxy: One, you can't change the pitch of ambient sounds dynamically; and two, due to a glitch in the doppler effect of this device, anything that moves with an overall velocity higher than 10000 while playing a sound makes the game crash.
I never got the fmod one to work. It makes the game crash when it loads sounds that don't come with the original game (ie: sounds from mods).
So, I guess the best choice is to stay with the default Galaxy audio device.
I never got the fmod one to work. It makes the game crash when it loads sounds that don't come with the original game (ie: sounds from mods).
So, I guess the best choice is to stay with the default Galaxy audio device.
~♥~ Bless the Cute Emperor ~♥~
- Shadow
- Masterful
- Posts: 743
- Joined: Tue Jan 29, 2008 12:00 am
- Personal rank: Mad Carpenter
- Location: Germany
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
I had the same issue with FMOD like saya-chan (during playing AND developing on top of it), I recommend using Galaxy or OpenAL
- Hook
- Inhuman
- Posts: 754
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2008 11:21 pm
- Personal rank: UT99 Promoter/Admin
- Location: Minnesota USA
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Does anybody know what this setting does?
"DopplerSpeed=9000.000000"
Should it be changed for any reason?
"DopplerSpeed=9000.000000"
Should it be changed for any reason?
=Hook=(Member# 626)
HUTP Active Forums: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/forum
HUTP UT99 Community Portal: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/
OR: https://hermskii.com/hook/ut99_hutp/
UT99 Server -> CROSSBONES Missile Madness {CMM}
* Newest Versions of: PRO-Redeemers | PRO-SNIPER-Redeemers | PRO-SEEKER-Redeemers <-(the Original)
and Now with FOOD FIGHT and Frying Pan arena !!!
IP: 68.232.181.236:7777 <-(NEW IP to come)
UT99 MH Server -> {CMH} CROSSBONES Monster Hunt (MH) by Mars007 (The Original) - IP: 108.61.238.93:7777
HUTP Active Forums: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/forum
HUTP UT99 Community Portal: https://hooksutplace.freeforums.net/
OR: https://hermskii.com/hook/ut99_hutp/
UT99 Server -> CROSSBONES Missile Madness {CMM}
* Newest Versions of: PRO-Redeemers | PRO-SNIPER-Redeemers | PRO-SEEKER-Redeemers <-(the Original)
and Now with FOOD FIGHT and Frying Pan arena !!!
IP: 68.232.181.236:7777 <-(NEW IP to come)
UT99 MH Server -> {CMH} CROSSBONES Monster Hunt (MH) by Mars007 (The Original) - IP: 108.61.238.93:7777
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Galaxy works so far very good, if you configure it right - under XP, Vista and 7 you usally need to increase Latency from default 40 to 50 in order to eliminate occasional sound crackling. Also for better sound quality set the following:
OutputRate=44100Hz
EffectsChannels=32
Here is my sample configuration:
OutputRate=44100Hz
EffectsChannels=32
Here is my sample configuration:
Code: Select all
[Galaxy.GalaxyAudioSubsystem]
UseDirectSound=True
UseFilter=True
UseSurround=True
UseStereo=True
UseCDMusic=False
UseDigitalMusic=True
UseSpatial=False
UseReverb=True
Use3dHardware=False
LowSoundQuality=False
ReverseStereo=False
Latency=50
OutputRate=44100Hz
EffectsChannels=32
DopplerSpeed=9000.000000
MusicVolume=192
SoundVolume=224
AmbientFactor=0.700000
- Dr.Flay
- Godlike
- Posts: 3347
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2011 9:26 pm
- Personal rank: Chaos Evangelist
- Location: Kernow, UK
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Sorry to "necro-bump" but I feel I should add to this subject.
(For those who do not know, these extra audio renderers are packaged in the "Oldunreal-Multimedia-Patches (OMP) update pack")
http://www.oldunreal.com/utpatches.html
Using the Creative/EAX patched Galaxy renderer gives you access to the EAX profiles made for most of the default maps.
If I am playing original UT maps, I swap back to Galaxy.
1 major problem with this renderer is it loads the EAX config file for the intro city map, then if you play a map without a config, it will echo madly as it has not un-loaded the previous config. Re-loading the map again fixes it.
*NOTE*If you have the patched version, you will have a folder full of *.eol EAX config files in your UT folder. If you do not, you are missing out !
FMOD commonly will crash UT, giving an invalid sound format error. I did once have it working, but then it gave up, and so did I.
OpenAL has better/more accurate sound positioning, so if you use real surround-sound (like me) it is the best option.
NOTES
If you do not change the option "UseOriginalUnreal=True" to "False" the sounds do not behave correctly, and you can hear everything anywhere in the map.
OpenAL uses FMOD, so you cannot delete it, if you only want to use OpenAL.
Oldunreal's info is out of date. Always use the newest OpenAL driver from Creative Labs/nVidia if you have an nForce sound chip.
Their info is from before the companies joined together.
If you use the windows driver they have in the package, you will suffer with scratchy popping sound.
I have my own updated/repackaged version on my site (all the original distro is included). Feel free to use that one.
http://my.opera.com/dr-flay/blog/unreal
(For those who do not know, these extra audio renderers are packaged in the "Oldunreal-Multimedia-Patches (OMP) update pack")
http://www.oldunreal.com/utpatches.html
Using the Creative/EAX patched Galaxy renderer gives you access to the EAX profiles made for most of the default maps.
If I am playing original UT maps, I swap back to Galaxy.
1 major problem with this renderer is it loads the EAX config file for the intro city map, then if you play a map without a config, it will echo madly as it has not un-loaded the previous config. Re-loading the map again fixes it.
*NOTE*If you have the patched version, you will have a folder full of *.eol EAX config files in your UT folder. If you do not, you are missing out !
FMOD commonly will crash UT, giving an invalid sound format error. I did once have it working, but then it gave up, and so did I.
OpenAL has better/more accurate sound positioning, so if you use real surround-sound (like me) it is the best option.
NOTES
If you do not change the option "UseOriginalUnreal=True" to "False" the sounds do not behave correctly, and you can hear everything anywhere in the map.
OpenAL uses FMOD, so you cannot delete it, if you only want to use OpenAL.
Oldunreal's info is out of date. Always use the newest OpenAL driver from Creative Labs/nVidia if you have an nForce sound chip.
Their info is from before the companies joined together.
If you use the windows driver they have in the package, you will suffer with scratchy popping sound.
I have my own updated/repackaged version on my site (all the original distro is included). Feel free to use that one.
http://my.opera.com/dr-flay/blog/unreal
Last edited by Dr.Flay on Sat Mar 10, 2012 9:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
UT99.org House Rules
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG
- Sergeant Todd
- Adept
- Posts: 407
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2008 2:09 am
- Personal rank: Retired Jedi
- Location: Ocho Rios Jamaica
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
Galaxy. It's bulletproof.
Sergeant Todd
---------------
"I miss Olmos & BG, as a matter of frak'd!"
---------------
"I miss Olmos & BG, as a matter of frak'd!"
- Dr.Flay
- Godlike
- Posts: 3347
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2011 9:26 pm
- Personal rank: Chaos Evangelist
- Location: Kernow, UK
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
After going home and looking at my notes and configs I have edited/corrected my post.
I highly recommend those who stick with Galaxy, to install the EAX patched version.
I highly recommend those who stick with Galaxy, to install the EAX patched version.
UT99.org House Rules
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG
- Dr.Flay
- Godlike
- Posts: 3347
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2011 9:26 pm
- Personal rank: Chaos Evangelist
- Location: Kernow, UK
- Contact:
Re: UnrealTournament 99 sound quality issues
I have the Creative Labs patcher and files are in one convenient zip, on my page (link in the post above).
They are no longer findable on Creative's site
I have seen them hosted on a few other sites, but I decided to put them in 1 zip archive.
Shame they aren't well known/used. There would be EAX profiles for custom maps by now.
When I found it I re-played most of the classic maps again. Made me realise how blessed we are with custom content, when I never play any of the original maps anymore (shock-horror, not even facing worlds!)
They are no longer findable on Creative's site
I have seen them hosted on a few other sites, but I decided to put them in 1 zip archive.
Shame they aren't well known/used. There would be EAX profiles for custom maps by now.
When I found it I re-played most of the classic maps again. Made me realise how blessed we are with custom content, when I never play any of the original maps anymore (shock-horror, not even facing worlds!)
UT99.org House Rules
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG
ChaosUT https://chaoticdreams.org
Your Unreal resources: https://yourunreal.wordpress.com
The UT99/UnReal Directory: https://forumdirectory.freeforums.org
Find me on Steam and GoG